It’s between him or AI, but the number of casuals who say “D Rose would’ve been the goat PG if he was healthy” is crazy. He was great but he’s definitely one of the weakest MVPs in the modern era and wasn’t even a top 3 player in the world when he won his MVP.
I’m a Duncan fan but the guy kind of tends to get overrated. People downplay his lack of a scoring bag if you were to transport him to his era.