EACL 2024 reviews will come out today (19 Nov aoe), so this is the discussion for them.
UPDATE: The author response period will be from 21 Nov to 28 Nov.
EACL 2024 reviews will come out today (19 Nov aoe), so this is the discussion for them.
UPDATE: The author response period will be from 21 Nov to 28 Nov.
Can someone say, what are you watching: soundness or overall assessment?
Soundness: 3/4/3 Overall assessment: 3.5/3.5/2.5
Is it possible to pass for main or findings?
Good soundness and fine overall.
It seems 2.5 rather than 3 is the borderline. In this way, 3 is a positive score. Did I understand correctly?
I think 3.0 is the boarderline and plus and/or minus 0.5 is a weak leaning.
Huge chance of Findings (Fig 5a: https://aclanthology.org/2023.acl-long.report.pdf). The average soundness score is 3.3, and the average overall score is 3.17.
To me, the overall score seems similar to the excitement score (by its definition). Both overall and excitement score tends to be lower than the soundness score, and are more subjective.