I am considering a purchase as a student although it is really expensive.
What are your major criticisms of the framework laptop?
E.g.
- I have heard that it discharges battery even while powered off (a very serious issue IMO).
Also, I will be using win10/11 and fedora most likely. So any Linux-related issues (e.g. hardware support) I would really like to know.
Thanks for any ideas.
Since upgrading from Tiger Lake to the AMD 7640U, my two biggest gripes (loud fan and short battery life) have been resolved to my satisfaction. That leaves only the more minor issues:
- Speakers are not great. Generally not an issue since I’m usually on headphones (thank you, FW, for including the 3.5 mm headphone jack!), but when I do use the speakers, they often sound pretty muffled.
- After two years, I have still not gotten used to using the Function keys in order to page up/page down. A six-key layout for the arrows would have been far superior.
- Trackpad button click is still unreliable. Yes, you can tap the trackpad for the same effect, but that feels unintuitive to me and I would still greatly prefer physical mouse buttons that I can feel.
It doesn’t have buttons on trackpad like thinkpad.
Probably the touchpad and the display. Both are kinda average, so at this price probably below average. Also the edges for me on the front are a bit sharp where the keyboard and the case meet. Sometimes the speakers will buzz my esc key.
The fan curve isn’t optimized for the AMD, but that’s software.
Little things, but batch 1 and don’t regret it yet if that helps lol
- speakers suck
- no touch screen option
Literally just those two things
If they fix those (and keep releasing new updates every year with regular cadence) then I really have a dream laptop option whenever I need an upgrade
Edit: oh also… the framework logo button on the keyboard… it’s an entire keyboard button! In a prominent corner spot. What is it for? Opening the framework website? That’s just dumb. It’s a super prominent keyboard key. Find a proper use for it, or just release a utility to let us customise it as an action button which can do whatever we want. It’s super bizarre. A minor issue - but very bizarre
If you’re on Linux, there should be an option in keyboard shortcuts to create a custom command for pressing that button.
Battery and you really need to consider every portion of the laptop. Updating drivers, ensuring the ssd chosen is low powered, enough ram at the right timing etc.
The only reason why I would consider a framework is because of the community. I am a tinkerer and thus far, in the last 15 years kf laptop ownerships. I have never encountered a laptop that did not have an issue. Take for example the thinkpad x1 extreme gen2 that had its display brightness cut in half over a driver update that was never fixed. Lenevo in that instance never cared to fix that issue and burried it among a sea of laptops they sell. However, framework has thus far two models, and when something does work, it shows. So expect support for major issues from both framework and the community. Also, if you happen to come accross a major issue with your build such as a desing issue, you dont need to scrap the laptop on the long term. You can simply upgrade when ever another part becomes available. It is like the other redditor said, it is on the long term that it becomes interesting.
- the optional ethernet adapter sticks out a bit (the RJ45 connector would be too large otherwise)
- the earlier models have a reflective screen
- having to use the
Fn
key forhome
end
pgup
pgdn
is more of an annoyance than I expected coming from a ThinkPad with dedicated keys - it’s sort of spoiled me for working on other laptops
Missing home/ end/ PgUp/ down keys is actually the biggest reason why I still haven’t bought one. I just don’t want to take the risk.
I am curious, what is your use case for those ? When do you use those ?
Acccount gone, weird. Fn +those keys and you have them again. With linux yiu maybe can swap em. Wonder if my framebook bios allow to swap the default.
I have no issues with my framework keyboard. Love it. I dislike ghe windows logo, could have been a gear or tux but ow well
I think you replied to the wrong comment. I was asking what was the use case for Pg Up/Down and Home/End that prevented OP to buy a Framework
Personally, I tend to use vim modes everywhere so I don’t really need those but I always thought that on a laptop they were too far away to be useful anyhoo.
I know, sadly that user is gone and wanted to reply. Its a good question you have, cause i have a fw and my left hand holds Fn, right hand does what page up or home or end i need to press. You know what i miss? The pause button. Kinda wish i could swap default fn function but at ghe same time, im ok with this arrangement. Nonidea why OP of this subthread doesnt go for a dedicated keyboard or ghe FW16 with full keyboard mod.
Ok ok. I thought you were the another account of the same person
Uh, I have a fw13 12th and f5 is actually a play/pause button
Not to speak for the previous poster, but I use these all the time in my web browser and in PDF-viewing software (evince). They’re pretty useful.
All the time in programming. Jump to the start/end of the line, quickly scrolling through logfiles, source files, documentation etc.
Yes, most of them can probably be replaced by some other key combination. But it will be a different shortcut for each tool, and I don’t feel like remembering multiple combinations just to navigate a file using a keyboard.
I also miss the dedicated
pgup
/pgdown
buttons a fair bit. It’s nice to have universal physical buttons for reading, works in every app.I also miss dedicated mouse click buttons, especially for middle click on linux. But I can get over this.
Consider it an investment, you’ll save money in the long run if you upgrade the hardware, and it doesn’t cost an arm and a leg to repair. Fedora support isn’t that good according to their graph, but windows support is nice from what I’ve experienced so far with it. Maybe one criticism I have for it would be the lack of a touchscreen/stylus option? I used to own a surface and aside from the maddening hardware issues I had with it, I did enjoy stylus and touch support
I got my AMD 13 two days ago. Using Fedora 39. The most disappointing things for me so far are the touchpad (it’s nowhere near the macbook ones) and the battery life. I would absolutely pay for a higher capacity battery. On the other hand, FW is light and maybe it’s time for me to invest in a powerbank.
It’s too nice and I don’t want to put stickers on it.
Get a second top shell from the marketplace and sticker up one of them and swap to the clean one for ‘professionalism’.
How much time and effort does it take to exchange the top shell?
No idea.
Consider a laptop out of the outlet store, if price is your issue
- shits out battery faster in sleep than running
- probably is self aware of this fact, since it likes to wake itself up and cook itself in my backpack
- gaping security holes, 12th gen already abandoned in terms of bios updates (read: none)
- Awful support that reply once every 48 hours, and ask you to repeat things from the last message you sent
- keyboard scratches the screen
- loud fans
- runs hot
- framework stans are annoying
- expensive
- shipping costs take the piss (still)
- they expect you to buy new shit (so very sustainable) when they ship broken HDMI and DP ports
- many promises made that were never made good on
Battery Life and no Touchscreen. That’s kind of it to be honest.
Assuming you are talking about the new AMD 13 I would avoid windows 10. My biggest downfall was drivers install and weak wifi 6e reception. I am running windows 11 but now that everything is installed right it has been great and the wifi 6e picks up most of of the time over the 5ghz band.
The common ones I’ve seen are weak speakers, display hinges (much more infrequent), the case being made of a softer aluminum, display brightness (not quite sure why this pops up, but it does), trackpad quality, and battery life under Linux.
I literally used the display in direct sunlight on a bright day, how the hell did screen brightness come up.
Everything else i either agree or can confirm
Also the up and down arrow keys being miniature, and the page up/down and home/end requires both the arrows and the fn key from the opposite side of the keyboard.
display brightness (not quite sure why this pops up, but it does)
Can you explain? You like the brightness?
I managed to get a significant dent in the bottom of the case on my first day carrying it to work. I’d never dented a laptop before. I have a hard case for it now.
I would like to buy a hard case too. Where did you get it from?