AISTATS 2024 paper reviews are supposed to be out today. I thought to create a discussion thread for us to discuss any issue/complain/celebration or anything else.
There is so much noise in the reviews every year. Some good work that the authors are proud of might get a low score because of the noisy system, given that AISTATS is growing large these years. We should keep in mind that the work is still valuable no matter what the score is.
I got A/A/BR/R, and the “R” reviewer put maximum confidence. Is it worth to trying rebut this? Also, I’m kind of surprised on the variance of the reviews.
You have two As. You should submit rebuttals without any doubt.
Thanks, I’ve talked to my advisor and we discussed it’s worth a try mainly because the arguments of R are rebuttable. I’ll be updating what happens at the end of the line.