maegul (he/they)

A little bit of neuroscience and a little bit of computing

  • 104 Posts
  • 1.41K Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: January 19th, 2023

help-circle




  • I started watching that a while ago and noped out pretty early on the basis that they may have a very good and well thought out point (the video is an impressive ~5hrs and tight too) … but also took something essential out of what it means to watch and resonate the show, something essentially Lynchian and tied the reason why he has fans.

    I don’t think this is just the nature of “explaining Lynch” as nothing about Mulholland drive ever felt that way, for eg.

    Happy to be talked down from this of course!






  • As a nerd, I don’t like the end of the article where she says we need to get revenge on the nerds.

    I hear you, as many would I think. But realistically, I think calling tech culture into question, even beyond its manifestation in the psychotic tech CEO types, is worth while. It’s really had a dominant run both materially and culturally (a revenge as many would see it), and I think it’s worthwhile questioning the value of a lot of it, in a way I don’t think many nerds and tech people are capable of (sadly IMO).

    There may be an inclination to separate the capitalism and nerdy parts. But as an industry/profession/whatever that generally tends to care a lot about itself in various ways … I think tech is disturbingly uninterested in caring about the quality of its profession beyond the bike shedding stuff let alone acting on it in any collective way. There are reasons for this, but given the dominance tech now has in the world, pushing back in the culture wholesale is justified I think.


  • If you just wanted to get a sense of the vibe and maybe the influence of the show, a minimum of 3-5 episodes could get you somewhere.

    But as for season 2 not being worth it, I don’t think that’s true. There’s a middle patch, from about episodes 9-20 or so. Look it up, there’ll be guides out there. These are the episodes where Lynch kinda left the show. Watching the parts he was involved in though is probably worth it. Especially as you’ll get the conclusion and the head in to season 3, where part of what season 3 is about has to do with the bigger picture of how it continues on from season 2.









  • Interesting! I haven’t seen Murnau’s, but Herzog’s and Coppola’s (if that counts). Interestingly, I don’t remember much of Herzog’s at all apart from enjoying Kinski.

    Which forces me to wonder if it isn’t that great a story, or at least not worth remaking. I’m not convinced that the whole “he’s coming” thing, after having literally been in his castle for a whole sequence, really works. I think in the three tellings of the story I’ve seen (including Eggers’), I’ve probably felt a let down from that structure.