New AI tools aim to help with grading, lesson plans—but may have serious drawbacks.

In a notable shift toward sanctioned use of AI in schools, some educators in grades 3–12 are now using a ChatGPT-powered grading tool called Writable, reports Axios. The tool, acquired last summer by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, is designed to streamline the grading process, potentially offering time-saving benefits for teachers. But is it a good idea to outsource critical feedback to a machine?

Writable lets teachers submit student essays for analysis by ChatGPT, which then provides commentary and observations on the work. The AI-generated feedback goes to teacher review before being passed on to students so that a human remains in the loop.

“Make feedback more actionable with AI suggestions delivered to teachers as the writing happens,” Writable promises on its AI website. “Target specific areas for improvement with powerful, rubric-aligned comments, and save grading time with AI-generated draft scores.” The service also provides AI-written writing prompt suggestions: “Input any topic and instantly receive unique prompts that engage students and are tailored to your classroom needs.”

  • jadero@programming.dev
    2·
    8 months ago

    Thanks! I’ve been working on this idea for quite a while. I post summaries and random thoughts occasionally hoping to refine my thinking to the point at which I’ll feel comfortable writing a proper essay.

    I like the name you’ve given the overarching system. That’s been a bit of a struggle for me, so you’ve given me a better concept to work with. “Large Sensory Input Model” captures my thoughts better than my own “the brain is just a kind of LLM.” That it’s abbreviation “LSIM” also conjures connections to “simulation” is a bonus for me, because that also addresses my thoughts on how we understand some things and other people.

    There is a fairly old hypothesis that something called “Theory of Mind” is basically our brain modelling and simulating other brains as a way to understand and predict the behaviour of others. That has explanatory power: empathy, stereotypes, in/out groups, better accuracy with closer relationships, “living on” through powerful simulations of those closest to us who have died, etc.

    Thanks for the feedback!