Oh now All-Pros matter? Certainly not when Peyton had 7 and Tom 3. 🙃

A hill I’m willing to die on is Eli Manning is a textbook Hall of Famer. This isn’t the hall of best stats folks. If you are telling the story of the NFL, you don’t leave out Eli Manning beating 7 Time Super Bowl Champion Tom Brady TWICE including against the perfect season. He’s got the logevity, he’s got the bulk stats, he’s got Rings. Jim Plunkett is the only eligible 2 time winner who isn’t in.