• 166 Posts
  • 11.7K Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 14th, 2023

help-circle











  • Ukraine and Russia is not a civil war by any measure

    The entire conflict in the Donbas was driven by the hyped up divided between “ethnic” Ukrainians and Russians. Hell, the Maidan Revolution was explicitly a civil conflict between Russian allied Ukrainians and Ukrainian Nationalists.

    The real Russian core is Moscow - St.Petersburg and the surrounding areas.

    Moscow and St. Petersburg are farther apart than Estonia and Poland. These have always been distinct power centers within Russia.

    So much of the discussion of this war is totally America-Brained, where you cannot see subpopulations and cultural carve-outs that aren’t made explicit by national borders. Nevermind these borders are themselves constantly in flux and contingent on the political alignments of the local ruling class.

    But Ukrainians had wanted independence and even (wrongly) welcomed Nazi invaders

    The Banderite nationalists, Makhnovshchina, Ukrainian Leninists, Lypyns’kyi-ists… these are all distinct historical factions often in armed conflict with one another. None of them are representative of the current EU-friendly corporate conglomeration governing the country.

    Zelensky isn’t a nationalist in any meaningful sense. Neither was Poroshenko. They’ve both been happy enough to auction off Ukrainian sovereignty for foreign investment and aid.

    The point is that Ukrainians see themselves as cousins of Russians but not as Russian.

    There is a strain of Ukrainian nationalism that sees itself as distinct from Russians and a strain of pan-Slavic Ukrainianism that sees these groups as overlapping. And then there are non-Slavic Ukrainians that don’t fit either demographic (Jewish Ukrainians, most famously, eat a lot of shit, but so do Roma and Turks and Arabs, etc, etc).

    All of these fractures are ripe for political wedging and other fuckery. And that’s exactly what international business has exploited since the collapse of the USSR. Everyone’s alienated from one another. Mass media is screaming that you’re being robbed by your “foreign” neighbors. And weapons have flooded the country to make the induced paranoia of a material threat.


  • My head canon is always converting magic into sci fi.

    Arthur C. Clarke will be by to collect royalties.

    Doesn’t really explain the Snitch though, other than “they’re more about tradition than logic”.

    Lots of sports spring out of a bunch of silly children’s games that get increasingly bureaucratic to sell tickets.

    Why not end the game with a timer or at a certain score count? Why introduce a fairy trapped in a golden ball who has some kind of personality, rather than just being a buzzing semi-invisible toy? Why not yadda yadda?

    Rowling definitely left a lot on the table.


  • Blaming the war in Ukraine on Russophobia is about as reasonable as blaming the war in Iran on their chants of ‘death to America’.

    It’s a bad comparison, as Ukraine/Russia is functionally a civil war over a border that didn’t matter until the USSR dissolved. Iran/US is a proxy war over Israel’s expansion into Lebanon.

    Much like with the breakup of Yugoslavia and subsequent genocidal border wars, the fight between Ukraine and Russia has been manufactured by Western political interests seeking to run both countries down. That’s why the US is sending money and weapons to both countries.

    By contrast, we’re not standing up Iran’s military.






  • Like most team sports have you work as a team to score points. Everyone participates and are more or less responsible for the outcome of the game.

    A better writing of the game would have had other players working as a team to spot the Snitch. Or alternative strategies for leveraging the extra player in the early game, when finding the Snitch was unlikely. Or even just a history of the sport, or variations of amateur and professional rules, or a pro-league that got more than a casual mention for the first chapter of the fourth book and then never again.

    you have that and then you have one team member that is just more special than everyone else

    You could argue the pitcher in baseball or the QB in football fill a similar role.

    But yes, the need to make Harry a Mary Sue at every opportunity definitely dragged on the series. The better parts of the series were when he wasn’t the center of attention and was more just an observer of a magical world.